The issues come when that decision is not so obvious. As experience in a specific call type grows, it will become second nature what the go-to tool cache should be. There is no doubt that our effectiveness on an incident scene is dramatically impacted by the tools and equipment that we choose to bring with us from the apparatus.
Unfortunately, it was not until the last couple of years that I was introduced to a tool that has been on the market for some time, the New York Hook. Bob Farrell, of Fire Hooks Unlimited, was the first to take this tool to market after being developed through his vast experience while serving with the FDNY. The New York Hook is greatly under-utilized in fire service as a whole. I have found this to be especially true in many western states. Here is why it needs to be added to the tools your department carries on its apparatuses:
While the pike pole has long been used for pulling ceilings, it does have its drawbacks with the modern use of drywall. The penetration that the pike pole provides through older materials like lathe-and-plaster is almost a downfall on drywall. Instead of instantly pulling large sections of ceiling, it often leaves a hole no bigger than the tool itself. This is where the hook's blunt edges make a world of difference. The shape of the head allows for the tool to grab, rather than puncture, when pulling. Also, little is lost in terms of penetration as the top edge of the tool is tapered. As with any tool, technique is still required, but in terms of general effectiveness, go to the hook first when drywall is encountered.
There are numerous applications where the hook is effective as a prying tool. It was originally created for roof operations and has no issue in pulling hatches, skylights, and the levers created by our saws during vertical ventilation. Unlike the pike pole, the hook has been incorporated into the realm of forcible entry as well. When married with a halligan, the leverage created is well beyond that of what even two firefighters are able to create with conventional irons work. The tool will generally make quick-work of many burglar bars that are encountered. (I do need to stress that the tool must have a steel handle if it is going to be used to pry. Fiberglass versions of tool will likely fail when subjected to large amounts of force. Skip the fiberglass handles whenever possible.)
For those with influence on your department's purchasing decisions, I would highly suggest adding a few hooks to your apparatuses. Bonus points for those who purchase one out of their own pocket.
We should be continually reviewing why we do what we do. Part of that process includes figuring out whether there is a more effective way to accomplish these tasks. Sometimes all it takes is a slight change in tools we are using.
The internet is full of videos highlighting the various uses of the New York Hook. For more info, check out firehooksunlimited.net. Our brothers at the Fire Service Warrior also produced a great article on the many uses of the tool. Check it out at http://www.fireservicewarrior.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/NY-Roof-Hook-Final.pdf.